The Rules of Contagion_Why Things Spread - and Why They Stop by Adam Kucharski

Author:Adam Kucharski [KUCHARSKI, ADAM]
Language: eng
Format: epub
Tags: Science, health, Sociology, History
ISBN: 9781788160193
Goodreads: 52949562
Publisher: Wellcome Collection
Published: 2020-02-13T00:00:00+00:00

IT’S NOT JUST ONLINE CONTENT itself that can create conflict; it’s also the context surrounding it. Online, we come across many ideas and communities we may not encounter much in real life. This can lead to disagreements if people post something with one audience in mind, only to have it read by another. Social media researcher danah boyd (she styles her name as lower case) calls it ‘context collapse’. In real life, a chat with a close friend may have a very different tone to a conversation with a co-worker or stranger: the fact that our friends know us well means there’s less potential for misinterpretation. Boyd points to events like weddings as another potential source of face-to-face context collapse. A speech that’s aimed at friends could leave family uncomfortable; most of us have sat through a best man’s anecdote that has made this mistake and misfired. But while weddings are (usually) carefully planned, online interactions may inadvertently include friends, family, co-workers, and strangers all in the same conversation. Comments can easily be taken out of context, with arguments emerging from the confusion.27

According to boyd, underlying contexts can also change over time, particularly as people are growing up. ‘While teens’ content might be public, most of it is not meant to be read by all people across all time and all space,’ she wrote back in 2008. As a generation raised on social media grows older, this issue will come up more often. Viewed out of context, many historical posts–which can linger online for decades–will seem inappropriate or ill-judged.

In some cases, people have decided to exploit the context collapse that occurs online. Although ‘trolling’ has become a broad term for online abuse, in early internet culture a troll was mischievous rather than hateful.28 The aim was to provoke a sincere reaction to an implausible situation. Many of Jonah Peretti’s pre-BuzzFeed experiments used this approach, running a series of online pranks to attract attention.

Trolling has since become an effective tactic in social media debates. Unlike real life, the interactions we have online are in effect on a stage. If a troll can engineer a seemingly overblown response from their opponent, it can play well with random onlookers, who may not know the full context. The opponent, who may well have a justified point, ends up looking absurd. ‘O Lord make my enemies ridiculous,’ as Voltaire once said.29

Many trolls–of both the prankster and abuser kinds–wouldn’t behave this way in real life. Psychologists refer to it as the ‘online disinhibition effect’: shielded from face-to-face responses and real-life identities, people’s personalities may adopt a very different form.30 But it isn’t simply a matter of a few people being trolls-in-waiting. Analysis of antisocial behaviour online has found that a whole range of people can become trolls, given the right circumstances. In particular, we are more likely to act like trolls when we are in a bad mood, or when others in the conversation are already trolling.31

As well as creating new types of interactions, the internet is also creating new ways to study how things spread.

Download

Copyright Disclaimer:
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.