Erfolgreich beteiligt? by Kubicek Herbert - Lippa Barbara - Koop Alexander

Author:Kubicek, Herbert - Lippa, Barbara - Koop, Alexander
Language: deu
Format: epub
Published: 2011-02-03T00:00:00+00:00

4

e-PB Belo Horizonte, Brasilien

http://opdigital.pbh.gov.br/

Beteiligungsgegenstand: Vorgegebene Projekte mit größerer Reichweite, über deren Umsetzung entschieden werden soll

Beteiligungsmöglichkeiten: Internet-Plattform mit e-Voting und Online-Forum

Zielgruppe: Wahlberechtigte Anwohner ab 16 Jahren

Initiator: Stadt Belo Horizonte

Zeitraum: 1. November bis 12. Dezember 2006

Aktuelle Situation: Seit 2006 alle zwei Jahre

4.1 Erfolgskriterien

Erfolgskriterien (Erhebungsfragen) Belege Bewertung 111

Lösungsrelevante Informationen 3,0

Inwieweit waren die Beiträge / Diskussionen sachlich und themenorientiert? (Input) ʺAnother strategy employed by active users of the forum - those who write a post - consisted of bypassing the moderation in order to make other comments that did not directly concern the e-PB. Consequently, these users, after having a few comments refused, developed the strategy of making combined comments - that is, sending a post where they would make a comment directly related to the process of the e-PB and in the same post make other demands that, if... made separately, would have been refused by the moderator. These ‘combined comments,ʹ however, did not have any substantial effect on biasing the main focus of the forums, as the majority of the discussions concerned the public works of the e-PB.″ 4,0

ʺAs to the recurrent argument that forums that allow anonymous participation are not bound by the normal conventions of reciprocity, blocking offensive posts was rarely necessary and was a minor part of the moderatorʹs work. Needless to say, potential offenders that could jeopardize the debate might have been discouraged either by knowing beforehand that the forums were moderated or by having their posts blocked at their first attempt.ʺ

„...evidence suggests that the online forum was, overall, an environment of rational, argumentative and reflective debates where active participants would persuade and be persuaded of the importance of one public work over another and where readers - in larger numbers - could be informed on concurrent perspectives.ʺ (1)

Wie viele Beiträge (und Kommentare) gingen ein? ʺEven though active participation in the forum was low (a total of 1,210 posts), all posts could be seen without logging in by all of those who accessed the link to the forums, where the number of readers was significantly higher than the number of posts.ʺ ʺTotal of e-votes: 503,266ʺ (1) 4,0

Download

Copyright Disclaimer:
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.