Against Intellectual Property (LvMI) by N. Stephan Kinsella

Against Intellectual Property (LvMI) by N. Stephan Kinsella

Author:N. Stephan Kinsella [Kinsella, N. Stephan]
Language: eng
Format: mobi
Publisher: Ludwig von Mises
Published: 2010-12-30T00:00:00+00:00


Trademarks

Palmer also argues that trademark law is legitimate.93 Suppose some Lachmannian changes the name on his failing hamburger chain from LachmannBurgers to Rothbard Burgers, which is already the name of another hamburger chain. I, as a consumer, am hungry for a RothbardBurger. I see one of the fake RothbardBurger joints run by the stealthy Lachmannian, and I buy a burger. Under current law, Rothbard, the “owner” of the RothbardBurgers trademark, can prevent the Lachmannian from using the mark RothbardBurgers to sell burgers because it is “confusingly similar” to his own trademark. That is, it is likely to mislead consumers as to the true source of the goods purchased. The law, then, gives a right to the trademark holder against the trademark infringer.

In my view, it is the consumers whose rights are violated, not the trademark holder’s. In the foregoing example, I (the consumer) thought I was buying a RothbardBurger, but instead got a crummy LachmannBurger with its weird kaleidoscopic sauce. I should have a right to sue the Lachmannian for fraud and breach of contract (not to mention intentional infliction of emotional distress and misrepresentation of praxeological truths). However, it is difficult to see how this act of fraud, perpetrated by the Lachmannian on me, violates Rothbard’s rights. The Lachmann-ian’s actions do not physically invade Rothbard’s property. He does not even convince others to do this; at most, he may be said to convince third parties to take an action within their rights, namely, to buy a burger from the Lachmannian instead of Rothbard. Thus, it would appear that, under libertarianism, trademark law should give consumers, not trademark users, the right to sue trademark pirates.

Moreover, more novel extensions of trademark, such as rights against trademark dilution or against certain forms of cybersquatting, cannot be justified. Just as a trademark holder does not have a right to his mark, neither does he have a right against his mark’s dilution. The law against cybersquatting is simply based on an economically ignorant opposition to “scalping” and arbitrage. There is, of course, nothing wrong with being the first to acquire a domain name and thereafter selling it to the highest bidder.



Download



Copyright Disclaimer:
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.
Popular ebooks
The Daily Laws by Robert Greene(1580)
BANKING ON IT by Anne Boden(631)
State Aid and Tax Law by Unknown(627)
609 Credit Repair Series: Template Letters & Credit Repair Secrets Workbook by Caulfield Bradley(613)
Antitrust by Amy Klobuchar(506)
Every Landlord's Guide to Finding Great Tenants by Janet Portman(505)
A Short & Happy Guide to Bitcoin, Blockchain, and Crypto by Del Wright Jr(488)
An Introduction to International Investment Law by David Collins(486)
Asperger Syndrome Employment Workbook: An Employment Workbook for Adults with Asperger Syndrome by Roger N. Meyer(485)
The Law and Business of International Project Finance: A Resource for Governments, Sponsors, Lawyers, and Project Participants by Scott L. Hoffman(476)
Private Equity Compliance by Jason A. Scharfman(467)
Against Intellectual Property (LvMI) by N. Stephan Kinsella(457)
Understanding Construction Contracts by Akhtar Surahyo(418)
Drafting Contracts: How and Why Lawyers Do What They Do, Second Edition by Tina L. Stark(410)
Advances in Mergers and Acquisitions by Cooper Cary L.;Finkelstein Sydney;(395)
Transactional Skills: Contract Preparation and Negotiating (What to Do — and What Not to Do) by Peter Siviglia(392)
Legal Tech, Smart Contracts and Blockchain by Unknown(392)
Green Public Procurement under WTO Law by Rika Koch(368)
Mediation: The Roles of Advocate and Neutral (Aspen Casebook Series) by Folberg Jay & Golann Dwight(362)
The Income Approach to Property Valuation by Nunnington Nick & Mackmin David & Baum Andrew(347)